GUEST POST: Smile, There’s a Great Big Beautiful Tomorrow

by A. Enigma

 

EPCOT. Everyone knows Epcot; Disney World’s second gate, a self proclaimed ‘Permanent World’s Fair’ that bores children with its slow educational dark rides while their parents get drunk in World Showcase and is for some reason getting a Guardians of Galaxy ride. But few people know what it was originally intended to be by the man himself, Walt Disney.

The Experimental Prototype Community of Tomorrow: perhaps Disney’s most frustrating acronym and Walt’s original reason for buying up a patch of Florida swamp twice the size of Manhattan. His idea for the area was to build a Utopian city of the future where people would live and captains of industry would be encouraged to set up shop and use it place as a testing ground for their new inventions and ideas. It would serve as a shining example to other American cities of how technology could be used to better the lives of all.

Walt would work on his plans for his dream city to the day he dies and the company would shelve the project, still early in its development, no longer having Walt’s ambition to to make it work.

But, while the idea would never come to fruition in reality, Disney did tap upon it in film form with their 2015 film Tomorrowland. Only having it be in another dimension instead of on Earth. And naming it after the section of Disneyland and Magic Kingdom parks instead of Epcot (because frankly, Tomorrowland sounds cooler). And not having it be Walt’s dream child and giving only the vaguest implication that he had anything to do with the city at all. ….none of which is the least bit important here. Whatever.

Anyway, the important thing is the movie’s iconic scene, or at least the scene the film’s promotional stuff heavily relied on, that of a young girl standing in a field of wheat looking off in the distant at a gleaming white citadel that contains all the hopes and the dreams of the past and the present. It’s really quite wonderful.

Now I know what you’re think: what in God’s name does this have to with Doctor Who?

Continue reading

SCARVES AND CELERY – “Worse than Everybody’s Aunt!”: Authority Figures, Childhood, and Trauma in “The Eleventh Hour”

I’m going to start this essay with a content warning. Towards the end of this article, I will be discussing themes of child sex abuse and PTSD, and the way they relate to “The Eleventh Hour”. A fair chunk of this essay won’t be discussing those themes, so I’ve made it clear in the body of the essay when we do start approaching them. But if people would rather not read at all for the sake of self care, then I fully understand. I hope I’ve handled the discussion of those themes respectfully.


As the Moffat era draws to a close, let’s go back to where it all began. The Eleventh Doctor clinging on to a crashing TARDIS, and a little girl with a crack in her wall praying to Santa.

Continue reading

Exorcizing “Exile” – a live-post of the worst Who story ever made

As you’ve seen, we got our first female Doctor.

We are very very very happy about it.

Except, of course, there is another story, before that one, featuring a female Doctor. A Big Finish story, set in an alternate universe, as part of the Unbound range. Starring Arabella Weir and David Tennant. Written by Nicholas Briggs.

Exile“.

The worst Who story ever made.

A story so bad it deserves a sort of ritualistic sending-off – now that it is irrelevant, that it has truly been sent into the trashbin of history, it deserves a methological dissection and assassination.

We are obliged to provide. Even if it costs us our sanity. Scribbles, Tibby (who is discovering the story!) and special guest Janine Rivers are on the case.

Pray for their souls.

CONTENT WARNING – transphobia, sexism, discussions of suicide, self-harm and addiction. Continue reading

THE TRUTH SNAKE – San Diego Comic Con 2017 recap, Thursday edition

This entry’s going to be a little bit different. As was mentioned previously, I have had the privilege of attending this year’s San Diego Comic Con, something I have not done in some time. As a trip to Comic Con covers so many different areas, this entry will be divided into largely unrelated subcategories, each to discuss some of the most prominent and exciting things I got to explore, in roughly chronological order.

Continue reading

TIBERIAN THOUGHTS – “Sir, I protest, I am not a Merry Man!”: Robot of Sherwood and narrative spaces

When things have gotten a bit political and complicated on here, you know what one must do?

Go and rave about series 8. Again. Be warned, it is not the first time, and it won’t be the last.

But not about the big, huge, dark setpieces. Not that I don’t have material on those, but let’s do something a little simpler and happier. “Robot of Sherwood”, here I come.

Continue reading

GUEST POST: An Age of Radicalisation – Doctor Who and Male Fandom

by Janine Rivers

I’ve been making a lot of noise recently.  Normally, elusive and enigmatic as I am, I stick to the shadows in an “Asylum of the Daleks-esque way, my footsteps echoing inside giant statues where my enemies seek to menace me.  Well, maybe not that last bit.  But over the last two weeks, I think I’ve gained more followers on Tumblr than I’ve had in my life.  A month ago I wasn’t even using the internet, but now it’s consumed me.

This isn’t autobiographical.  Well, it isn’t very autobiographical, but I’m terrible at writing in a neutral voice.  If this were an autobiographical post, it would go in my “diary”, or blog as it’s also referred to.  But today I’m doing something I never thought I would, and guest-writing a whole post on DoWntime.  There are reasons for that, beyond DoWntime just being brilliant – I feel like this is the right place for this particular post to go, because it brings a lot of what my lovely, far more intelligent colleagues have written into perspective.  Today, I’m here to talk about Doctor Who’s male fanbase.

Continue reading

Where are we now, and what’s next – an official communication from the DoWntime team

Welcome, dear readers!

After the continuous flow of content series 10 has brought to this blog, it seems like a good time to seat back and talk about our future a bit. Yes, “our” future, together and all that. We’re romantic that way. We like to talk to you like you’re a handsome guy/gal/pal we want to hit on at a little decrepit bar playing the last Kesha hit songs in a faraway ton. Sorry.

Because you could of course assume that the site is going into quasi-hibernation until Christmas and the arrival of Jodie Whittaker, our glorious Thirteenth Doctor, into the TARDIS – but no! There are plans being drawn. Of course, not all those plans are going to get off the ground right now; because some of them would require time, and most of all money, we don’t have right now. And while a Patreon seems absolutely like something we’ll end up doing eventually, we all think it’s only normal and fair to show our readers that we can sustain the blog and its quality levels on our own and for a while before asking for any kind of money. But some of those projects are going to materialize much sooner, and hopefully they’ll be very enjoyable for you!

Here goes a list.

  • From August forwards, we’ll be starting to put money into WordPress to supress all those pesky ads you’re getting. We’ve been told they make navigation on mobile kind of difficult. Hopefully that’ll help!
  • As you might have noticed, our new Doctor is female. This is one awesome piece of news, and we’re all overjoyed here. In fact, we’re so pleased we’re going to have a very special celebration next week – on Saturday, Tibère and Scribbles will be live-commenting the infamous Big Finish audio, “Exile”, aka the transphobic one with a female Doctor, before throwing it into the trashbins of history once and for all. Of course, it’s a rather tricky thing to set up a live you can watch as it unfolds with our level of equipment, so you’ll only get to read the final product. But don’t worry, it should be very funny. Especially if Tibère is trying to drown his sorrows. Which he will.
  • In two weeks and a bit, you’ll get a new weekly series on the site – entitled “Looking For Telos”, it’ll see Scribbles and Tibère marathoning the Classic series, watching a serial each week and offering thoughts and analysis!
  • Scribbles will be at Comic-Con next week, and will offer some coverage from there! He has promised many “blurry, shitty photos”. Trust him.

And of course, we’ll be preparing all throughout the year to set-up some really cool coverage of series 11, with a large panel of guests, old and new! We’ve been aware that the series 10 coverage might have been a bit lacking in diversity of commentators, and that is something we intend to fix, or at least try to fix, going forwards!

Thank you once again for reading and appreciating (or not!) the content we are putting forward on this blog – watch Who, and be happy!

 

Andrew, Sam and Kevin

ASSESSING STRESS, AUDIO EDITION: Torchwood, series 3 – “The Office of Never Was”

Welcome to DoWntime’s not-too-regular column, Assessing Stress. That’s where we assess … stress. Or more accurately, talk and debate about the newest episodes to hit the television screen, the new releases from Big Finish, and all these good things. Spoilers after the “read more” tag!

And today, Tibère and Scribbles tackle the latest Torchwood audio, “The Office of Never Was”!

doors closing”

going up!”

SPOILER-FREE THOUGHTS

SCRIBBLES: Rather excellent, all in all. Ianto’s always been a bit of an odd character in Torchwood, a focal point for fandom but rarely explored as the central focus onscreen. This is easily one of the meatiest explorations of him, and of his place in Torchwood. Every character in the series has a bit of darkness to them, and it was clear Ianto did judging by the whole keeping a Cyber-converted woman in the basement incident, but here, we really get to see him stripped down and desperate in a really wonderful way. It’s not quite the tallest triumph of this range, but it is very, very good at what it does, and what it does is something this range could always use. So, highly recommended, really.

TIBERE: It’s James Goss. Surmise. I mean, I know we do tend to praise him maybe a bit too much, and if we keep going a restraining order might be on its way, but still! The man is brilliant, and this is a perfect exploration of why his writing style is so good, and why it fits Torchwood so well. Admittedly, it’s not a revolution or anything, it doesn’t do the kind of things “Cascade” or “The Dollhouse” have done this year, and I think you could say there is a sort of comfortable Torchwood audio formula at work now – the writers have settled into their groove. But eh, said formula is terrific – taking, in every new story, a specific aspect of Torchwood and examining it in very critical, dark and upsetting ways. Can’t really mention what that story does in the spoiler-free part, but it manages to find a new and compelling angle to base a Ianto story on while being utterly faithful to the tone and principles of the show. It’s a lovely conceptual horror tale with absolutely stunning sound work and direction (seriously, can we agree that the TW audios have like, the tightest production work in all of BFdom?), and that’s plenty enough already.

Continue reading

SCARVES AND CELERY – DoWntime responds: Whovian Femisim’s review of “The Doctor Falls”

Today, I’m going to engage in something of a departure for this blog, by writing a response to the brilliant Whovian Feminism’s review of “The Doctor Falls”. Because I disagreed with quite a bit of her interpretation of the episode, and I wanted to write about why I disagreed with it, as I think doing so will help me say some useful things about the story and its themes. And also because she’s one of the people who is frequently critical towards Moffat who I have respect for, because I think there’s honesty and consistency to her approach that I find lacking in other critics – she won’t criticise the Moffat era for one thing and then let the Davies Era or classic Who off when they do exactly the same thing. And she recognises the genuine good done in the Moffat Era – heck, her review of “The Doctor Falls” ends on a positive sentiment about the episode itself, and she acknowledges the aspects of the episode that other people love – she just takes time to explain the problems she had with it, in an eloquent and thoughtful fashion. So I have a sense that a well written response could be a rare chance for a productive dialogue in fandom.

But I’m also nervous about doing this – partly about the possibility that I could fall flat on my face in a “debate” type of article, and just end up looking very stupid. But also (and I think this is much more important) I don’t want this to end up being the story of a straight white guy disagreeing with a queer woman and ending up stirring up a shitstorm, where she ends up getting harassed by trolls who take what is intended as a polite disagreement as a chance to be trolls to a woman on the internet. Heck, I don’t think that would happen – as far as I can tell she has a much bigger audience than we do here at DoWntime. But I do think it’s necessary to lay out a basic ground rule: everyone who’s reading this article, don’t be a jerk. And to Whovian Feminism: I really do think you’re great. Your tireless campaign for more female creators in Doctor Who and your support for a female Doctor is genuinely inspiring, and your reviews are always thought provoking, and challenge me to think about the problems with my favourite show in a valuable and constructive way.

Continue reading